Kelley Blue Book Homes

What Is the Most Accurate Home Value Estimator?

What the Published Numbers Show

Written by
Reviewed by
Aerial map of a neighborhood with one home linked to nearby homes

Published on Updated on 10 min readCites 16 sources

Fact checked

The short answer

Of eight popular home value estimators, only Zillow and Redfin publish a median error rate. Zillow reports 1.77% for listed homes and 7.20% for off-market homes (September 30, 2026). Redfin reports 1.90% and 7.44% (October 16, 2026). For an unlisted home, the off-market figure applies, a median miss of $43,200 to $44,640 on a $600,000 home.

By the published numbers, the most accurate home value estimator is the one with the lowest median error for homes like yours. We looked at eight popular estimators (Zillow, Redfin, Realtor.com, Homes.com, Chase, Bank of America, Pennymac and Kelley Blue Book Homes), and only Zillow and Redfin publish a median error rate. Their numbers sit close together. Whether your home is listed for sale right now matters far more.

You've probably pulled up a few estimates on your home and found they don't agree. On a $600,000 house, a few percentage points is tens of thousands of dollars. Below, each estimator is described from its own published page, with the date we read it. Kelley Blue Book Homes is one of the entries.

The tools are listed alphabetically, with what each one's own page says about it. An accuracy figure appears only where the company publishes one.

ToolWho publishes itWhat its page says about itPublished accuracy figure or target
Real Estate Center home value toolBank of AmericaAddress only. "For illustrative purposes only"None published
Home Value EstimatorChaseAddress, with variables you can adjustNone published
Home Valuation ReportHomes.comData from four automated valuation models, plus similar propertiesNone published
Free valuation reportKelley Blue Book HomesYour answers on condition and upgrades, neighborhood comps, local trends, appraisal-grade methodologyDesign target, within 3% of final sale price
Home Value EstimatorPennymacPublic data and market trends, with comps and mapsNone published
My HomeRealtor.comEstimate from your addressNone published
Redfin EstimateRedfinMLS data, updated daily for homes for sale and weekly off-market1.90% median error on the market, 7.44% off
ZestimateZillow120+ million homes, most updated multiple times per week1.77% median error on the market, 7.20% off

Zillow's page was last refreshed September 30, 2026. Redfin's was read October 16, 2026, and the rest in October 2026. "None published" means the page we read didn't give a figure. The Kelley Blue Book Homes report is free with no obligation.

Which is the most accurate home value estimator?

If you want to name the most accurate home value estimator by the numbers, Zillow and Redfin are the two you can measure, because they're the only estimators here that publish a median error rate. Zillow reports 1.77% for homes on the market and 7.20% for off-market homes, according to its Zestimate page last refreshed September 30, 2026. Redfin reports 1.90% and 7.44%, according to its Redfin Estimate page read October 16, 2026.

A median is a halfway mark. In Zillow's words, "for homes currently listed for sale, the Zestimate is within 1.77% of the final sale price half of the time, and within 7.20% half of the time for off-market homes." The other half land farther away, high or low.

On a $600,000 home, as an example, the gap between them is $780 for a listed home and $1,440 for one that isn't listed. Between listed and unlisted homes, each company's figure grows about fourfold. Zillow also notes that unreported additions, updates and remodels aren't reflected in the Zestimate. If you haven't listed yet, the off-market figure is the one that applies to you.

What do these error rates mean in dollars on a $600,000 home?

Each dollar figure below is the published percentage multiplied by $600,000, as an example.

EstimatePublished figure and sourceOn a $600,000 home (example)
Zestimate, listed1.77% median error (Zillow, September 30, 2026)$10,620
Zestimate, not listed7.20% median error (Zillow, September 30, 2026)$43,200
Redfin Estimate, listed1.90% median error (Redfin, October 16, 2026)$11,400
Redfin Estimate, not listed7.44% median error (Redfin, October 16, 2026)$44,640
Kelley Blue Book Homes reportDesigned to land within 3% of the final sale price (Kelley Blue Book Homes, October 2026)$18,000 either side

By Zillow's published median, half of off-market Zestimates on a $600,000 home land within $43,200 of the sale price and half land farther out. Redfin's halfway mark is $44,640. The Kelley Blue Book Homes figure is a design target. Zillow and Redfin publish median errors, so the numbers don't line up one for one.

A $43,000 swing shows up in real decisions. It can decide whether a downsizing budget covers the condo you want, or whether your list price draws early offers. Whichever tool you treat as the most accurate home value estimator, a closer look at your specific house is worth the time before you set a price. Our guide on how to price a home for sale shows how that number gets built.

How does the Redfin Estimate compare with the Zestimate?

Published accuracy is close. The differences are in data and refresh schedule, per Zillow's page of September 30, 2026 and Redfin's of October 16, 2026.

  • Data. Redfin says it uses MLS data, the records agents enter when a home is listed. Zillow says unreported additions, updates and remodels aren't reflected in the Zestimate.
  • Updates. Redfin updates daily for homes for sale and weekly for off-market homes. Zillow says most Zestimates update multiple times per week.
  • Coverage. Zillow publishes Zestimates for more than 120 million homes.
  • Appraisal status. Zillow says the Zestimate "is not an appraisal and can't be used in place of an appraisal." Redfin says its estimate "is not an appraisal or a substitute for the expert pricing advice of your real estate agent."

Does home value estimate accuracy vary by market?

Zillow publishes its on-market median error by metro, from 1.11% in Colorado Springs to 2.54% in San Francisco (Zillow, September 30, 2026). In Las Vegas it's 1.17%, or $7,020 on a $600,000 listed home, as an example. Our page on how accurate the Zestimate is in your metro covers the rest of the list.

Whatever your metro's figure, look up four local numbers before you trust any estimate.

  • Median days on market
  • Sale-to-list price ratio
  • Homes for sale right now
  • Price per square foot on recent nearby sales

The Kelley Blue Book Homes report also includes local pricing trends and market demand signals for your area. Kelley Blue Book Homes local housing market pages are on the way too, starting with Las Vegas and Clark County.

What do the other home value estimators publish about themselves?

Five more tools are on our list. None publishes an accuracy figure in the sources we read. Here's what each says it does, from its own page, read October 2026.

Realtor.com My Home

Realtor.com gives an estimate from your address (realtor.com/myhome, October 2026). Use it as a starting point for equity, which is what the home would sell for minus everything owed against it, including a first mortgage, any HELOC balance and any other lien. That figure is the first check on what a downsizing move could leave you.

Homes.com Home Valuation Report

Homes.com says its report "includes data from four different AVMs" and compares your home to similar properties (homes.com, October 2026). An AVM is the automated model behind most instant estimates. Drawing on more than one model is a reminder that estimates for the same address can differ.

Chase Home Value Estimator

Chase's estimator needs only an address and lets you adjust the home's variables to see how the estimate changes (chase.com, October 2026). Chase's page also lists three ways to estimate value. They are an online estimator, a comparative market analysis from an agent, and a professional appraiser.

Bank of America Real Estate Center

Bank of America's tool needs only an address. The bank says it's "intended to be used for illustrative purposes only and does not represent an appraisal or confirmation of actual home value" (homevaluerealestatecenter.bankofamerica.com, October 2026). Use it as one more number to put next to the Zestimate and Redfin Estimate in the check below.

Pennymac Home Value Estimator

Pennymac gives an instant estimate based on public data and market trends, with comparable sales and map views (pennymac.com, October 2026). Study the comps. If they don't match your home's size, age and condition, they pull the number with them.

Where does Kelley Blue Book Homes fit among home value estimators?

Kelley Blue Book Homes launched in July 2026 and is powered by True Footage, a national appraisal company trusted by lenders and real estate professionals. It starts with about five minutes of questions on your home's condition and recent upgrades, and the report accounts for layout and remodels too. Then it combines your answers with real neighborhood comps and local market trends.

The report is designed to land within 3% of the final sale price. It includes a custom value range, comparable homes from your neighborhood, local pricing trends, market demand signals and a local partner strategy session. The online estimates comparison explains the method in more detail. It's a valuation report built on appraisal-grade methodology. It isn't an appraisal, and it can't be used for a mortgage or lending transaction.

A number built around your house starts with your address. Enter it for the free report. It's ready in minutes, with no obligation.

When do you need an appraisal instead of an online estimate?

An appraisal is a formal opinion of value from a state-licensed appraiser, usually ordered by a lender before a mortgage or refinance. Zillow, Redfin, Bank of America and Kelley Blue Book Homes each say their number is something else.

A divorce or an estate can call for a formal number. Ask your attorney or tax professional whether you need an appraisal, and for which date. The home appraisal guide explains how the process works and how to order one before you list.

How should you check your home's value before you sell?

  1. Write down the Zestimate and the Redfin Estimate on your address, and note whether the home is listed.
  2. List what the public record may miss, such as remodels, additions, a new roof or condition issues.
  3. Look up your area's days on market, sale-to-list ratio, inventory and price per square foot.
  4. Get a valuation built from your answers and nearby closed sales. If it's far from the online figures, start with your list from step two.
  5. Ask any agent you interview for their listing success rate, the share of their listings that actually close, plus their days on market and sale-to-list ratio.

If you're downsizing, a $43,200 difference on a $600,000 home can be the difference between the condo you want and the one you'll settle for.

How Kelley Blue Book Homes can help

The next step is a number built around your house. Kelley Blue Book Homes gives you a free valuation report, ready in minutes and designed to land within 3% of the final sale price, with your condition and upgrades factored in.

Every report comes with a connection to a vetted local Kelley Blue Book Homes agent who has already seen your valuation before you speak. Kelley Blue Book Homes vets its Verified Agents on sales volume, days on market and sale-to-list ratio. Whoever you talk to, ours included, ask for their listing success rate, the share of the listings they take that actually close.

In select markets you can also see a cash offer from one of Kelley Blue Book Homes' integrated cash offer partners beside your report. Today those partners make offers in Washington, California, Colorado, Arizona, Texas, Georgia, Tennessee, Florida, North Carolina, South Carolina, Maryland, Virginia, the DC metro, Minnesota and Nevada. A cash offer trades price for speed. It typically comes in below market value, and how far below moves with the market. Kelley Blue Book Homes is a valuation and seller services platform. It doesn't lend, offer home equity loans or HELOCs, or buy houses. Enter your home address to get your free report, with no obligation.

Key Points to Remember

  • Of eight popular estimators, only Zillow and Redfin publish median error rates, Zillow at 1.77% listed and 7.20% off-market (September 30, 2026), Redfin at 1.90% and 7.44% (October 16, 2026).
  • On an unlisted $600,000 home, Zillow's 7.20% off-market median (Zillow, September 30, 2026) works out to $43,200.
  • Zillow's on-market median error runs from 1.11% in Colorado Springs to 2.54% in San Francisco (September 30, 2026), so check your own metro.
  • An appraisal comes from a state-licensed appraiser, usually ordered by a lender, and Zillow, Redfin and Bank of America each say their estimates are not appraisals.
  • The free Kelley Blue Book Homes valuation report is designed to land within 3% of the final sale price.

Frequently asked questions

What is the most accurate home value estimator?

Of eight popular home value estimators (Zillow, Redfin, Realtor.com, Homes.com, Chase, Bank of America, Pennymac and Kelley Blue Book Homes), only Zillow and Redfin publish a median error rate. Zillow reports 1.77% for listed homes and 7.20% off-market (September 30, 2026). Redfin reports 1.90% and 7.44% (October 16, 2026). Kelley Blue Book Homes says its free report is designed to land within 3% of the final sale price.

How accurate is the Redfin Estimate?

Redfin reports a median error of 1.90% for homes for sale and 7.44% for off-market homes (redfin.com/redfin-estimate, October 16, 2026). On an unlisted $600,000 home, 7.44% is $44,640. Redfin says its estimate is not an appraisal.

Is Zillow or Redfin more accurate?

By their own figures, Zillow and Redfin are close. Zillow reports a 1.77% median error on the market and 7.20% off (September 30, 2026). Redfin reports 1.90% and 7.44% (October 16, 2026). For both, the bigger difference is whether the home is listed.

How far off can a home value estimate be on a $600,000 home?

By the companies' own published medians, half of off-market Zestimates on a $600,000 home land within $43,200 of the sale price (Zillow, 7.20%, September 30, 2026), and half of off-market Redfin Estimates land within $44,640 (Redfin, 7.44%, October 16, 2026). The other half land farther away, high or low.

Is the Kelley Blue Book Homes valuation report an appraisal?

No. The Kelley Blue Book Homes report is a free valuation report built on appraisal-grade methodology. It isn't a lender appraisal and can't be used for a mortgage or lending transaction. An appraisal is a formal opinion of value from a state-licensed appraiser, usually ordered by a lender.

Why do home value estimators give different numbers for the same house?

They use different data and update on different schedules. Redfin uses MLS data and updates daily for homes for sale (October 16, 2026). Zillow says unreported remodels aren't reflected (September 30, 2026). Homes.com includes data from four automated models, and Pennymac uses public data (October 2026).

Sources

  1. Zillow, Zestimate page, last refreshed September 30, 2026, zillow.com/zestimate
  2. Redfin, Redfin Estimate page, read October 16, 2026, redfin.com/redfin-estimate
  3. Bank of America Real Estate Center, October 2026, homevaluerealestatecenter.bankofamerica.com
  4. Chase Home Value Estimator, October 2026, chase.com/personal/mortgage/calculators-resources/home-value-estimator
  5. Realtor.com My Home, October 2026, realtor.com/myhome
  6. Homes.com, October 2026
  7. Pennymac Home Value Estimator, October 2026, pennymac.com/home-value-estimator
  8. Kelley Blue Book Homes homepage and /online-estimates, October 2026
  9. Kelley Blue Book Homes /sell-my-house, /online-estimates and Common Questions, October 2026
  10. Kelley Blue Book Homes homepage and /find-an-agent, October 2026
  11. Kelley Blue Book Homes /agents, October 2026
  12. Kelley Blue Book Homes /cash-offer and /we-buy-houses, October 2026
  13. Kelley Blue Book Homes content program, October 2026
  14. Kelley Blue Book Homes, /kelley-blue-book-homes-launches (July 7, 2026) and site footer
  15. Kelley Blue Book Homes blog, What Is a Home Appraisal and How Does It Work?, August 31, 2026
  16. Arithmetic on the published Zillow, Redfin and Kelley Blue Book Homes percentages above, labeled as examples in the copy

About the author

Matt Hyatt

Chief Appraiser and General Manager at True Footage

SRA, ATA-R, and MNAA

Matt Hyatt is Chief Appraiser and General Manager at True Footage, the largest appraisal firm in the country. He brings 30 years of experience in the appraisal industry.